Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Zibb
Subscribe to HOTELS
Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

Full Throttle Franchising

More sophisticated investors seeking higher returns are fueling franchisors' pipelines. But with lenders growing circumspect, deal wheels may need to turn faster if this bullish run is to continue.

By Mary Scoviak -- Hotels, 10/1/2007

Which leading franchisor doesn't have a record pipeline? Private equity, banks, institutions, developers, high-net-worth individuals and existing franchisees hungry for a piece of the hotel industry's action are pushing big brands' development logs past the six-figure mark. “The cost of capital is still reasonable. Land costs generally are in line with revPAR and ADR. We are in a good cycle,” says S. Kirk Kinsell, newly named president of Europe, Middle East, Africa for InterContinental Hotels Group (IHG). Given the range of new directions for franchising, Kinsell and others aren't ruling out the possibility of another record-setting year.

Big Deals, Bigger Pipelines

One reason for optimism stems from the fact that franchise deals are getting bigger, more complex and becoming more of a standard option for sophisticated investors. Anyone with doubts only has to look as far as Blackstone's acquisition of Hilton Hotels Corp. “Merger and acquisition activity has had positive impact on growth. It has shone a bright light on the value and long-term viability of the franchising concept,” says Rajiv Trivedi, La Quinta's executive vice president for franchising.

Consolidation should continue to narrow the number of franchisors—but not their pipelines. “Further acquisitions are possible for companies that are missing a sector in their house of brands. Acquiring a brand with a good reputation is easier than trying to create a brand,” says Dorraine Lallani, senior vice president, Jones Lang LaSalle Hotels Select Service Division. “It remains to be seen what the implications of transactions such as Blackstone/Hilton will mean to franchisees. It should be interesting viewing.”

Closer to ground level, Chip Ohlsson, Starwood Hotels & Resorts' vice president of development, says more franchisees are developing “a portfolio of business in a specific segment and a specific region.” The rationale: “It allows them to market strategically to a specific exit strategy,” he says.

David Pepper, Choice Hotels International's senior vice president, franchise, development and emerging brands, reports an uptick in the number of developers interested in putting together regional development packages for five or more hotels and increased activity by mixed-use developers looking to anchor projects with hotels, particularly upper-end select-service brands.

Adds Jim Chu, Global Hyatt Corp.'s senior vice president of owner relations and franchise support, “New franchisees tend to have more development experience. They are multiple-property owners interested in upscale service brands.”

Savvy owners are leveraging their real estate expertise to create fresh options for franchising. Special-purpose concepts, such as a Holiday Inn waterpark fusion, are making the numbers work in areas such as Middle America, which otherwise would be below the development radar. Master-planned communities are making room for lifestyle hotels and all-suite hotels. “We've heard some mall developers and owners talking about monetizing surface parking by building hotels that will redefine the mall experience,” says Thomas Keltner, Hilton's executive vice president and CEO, Americas and global brands. “Diversity investors” are drilling deeper into underserved markets from the Carolinas to northern Florida and Texas.

Gas prices, the need to be near family and environmental issues are generating more opportunities in Los Angeles and other large urban areas, says Roger Bloss, CEO, Vantage Hospitality. “People don't want to commute as far today. If they move back to the cities, hotels will follow.” Developers reflagging failed boutiques or converting empty office space already are bringing mid-tier and even select-service offers to cities from New York to Chicago and Los Angeles.

Al Calhoun, managing director, Jones Lang LaSalle Hotels' Select-Service Division, says it is still more likely that secondary markets will keep brands' franchise pipelines flowing. “In the United States, given the difficulty in securing the top tier brands in the 'Top 25' markets, owners will be looking seriously at secondary markets that have long-term potential. The feeling is that they can be successful with superior brands in smaller markets,” Calhoun says. For the most part, that means site hunting in the Southeast and Southwest, as well as both coasts.

Improving The Offer

According to Jones Lang LaSalle Hotels' recent Hotel Investor Sentiment Survey, 40% of investors listed upscale hotels as their preferred asset class, while 20% expressed interest in luxury and mid-scale assets. This trend is also impacting franchising growth. “More franchisees want to migrate upstream. Chains that don't have offers to address that demand are going to lose owners from their systems,” says Tony Berger, COO, Wyndham Hotel Group.

Steve Belmonte, CEO of Vantage Hospitality's Lexington Collection, sees the same trend. “The generation of owners coming online are not building their parents' motels. They are focused on high-end hotels and new construction,” he says.

The flood of new prototypes and new brands plays directly to this demand. Few concepts are as hot as lifestyle. “Some developers have come to us asking about lifestyle concepts,” Keltner says. “Blackstone is doing some interesting things in that area. There is room for that kind of approach. But 15 boutique hotels aren't going to move the needle. And, too, there's the question of what is meant by lifestyle. A bar scene? High style? There are a lot of different lifestyles.”

Franchisees such as Marshall Management CEO Michael Marshall see the pros and cons of pioneering concepts. His concern is that new brands will weaken the distribution of brand-delivered room nights for a specific market. That said, however, “We will manage the aloft, Hyatt Summerfield, Staybridge and Indigo flags. Over time, these new brands will drive the older brands out of the market or seriously weaken them,” he says.

Not everyone is on board that trend. Dean Savas, Accor North America's senior vice president of franchising, is tracking more multi-unit developers who are considering developing in the economy segment, “where competition is not so great.” New construction “has increased significantly,” but conversion opportunities are also driving the pipeline, he says.

 

THE GIST

  • Value-engineering is driving down development costs with smaller footprints, reconfigured public spaces and lower staffing models. “Chains are squeezing out every penny they can from investment and operating expenses,” says Mark Siebert, CEO, iFranchise Group.
  • New investors are translating franchising from “potential” to real projects. “Some investors in China still want trophy assets. But there is a supply of new money that favors a mix of brands,” says Tony Berger, COO, Wyndham Hotel Group.
  • More and more regional companies in South America are looking at franchising. “Both operators and investors think that a franchise is the way to acquire international recognition without losing control over the administration of their properties,” says Arturo Garcia Rosa, president, HVS Argentina, and senior partner, HVS Global Hospitality Services.
  • Most franchised chains see Africa as too difficult. “With huge opportunities in India and China, they are leaving Africa to a later date—or not going there at all,” says Trevor Ward, managing director, W Hospitality Group. Some exceptions: IHG, which now has a South African office; US Franchise Systems, with a deal in Nigeria to develop Hawthorn Suites; and Wyndham Hotel Group, which is looking for opportunities to franchise Ramada and Days Inn.
  • India remains a complex franchising play. “It is short-term, but still a little farther out than China,” says Wyndham's Berger. Issues such as problems getting clear titles to land still need to be addressed, as does expansion of infrastructure. Financial and regulatory transparency is getting closer.

Not So Fast

Brands are announcing record pipelines. But John Q. Hammons, founder, chairman and CEO of John Q. Hammons Hotels & Resorts, predicts only 37% of those projects will ever come online. “I've been in this business a long time, and I know what big costs are doing,” he says. He contends that lenders will be taking a closer look at how they invest their money. Unless an investor is very well heeled, Hammons forecasts that more lenders will be saying “no.” That may not be a bad thing for the industry. “We have to be careful we don't get into an oversupply situation,” he says.

Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» VIEW ALL TALKBACK THREADS

Related Content

Related Content

 

By This Author

Hotels Marketplace

 
Advertisement

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Podcasts

Blogs

  • Laurence Geller
    HOTELS’ Insider

    May 19, 2008
    It's All About Supply
    It has been a year since the first glimmerings of economic problems surfaced to the public at large. Some ignored the issue while others thought an......
    More
  • Jeff Weinstein
    Editor's Viewpoint

    May 15, 2008
    Dubai In My Rear Window
    I have been back in the office from the Dubai hotel investment conference for more than a week and this is the first breath I have had to write thi......
    More
  • View All Blogs RSS
Advertisements





Newsletters
Get hotels industry news, trends, and business information delivered directly to your inbox!

HOTELS' Daily News Service (Daily)
Food & Beverage Bites (Monthly)
HOTELS eMarketplace (Monthly)
About Us   |   Advertising Info   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   FREE Subscription   |   Useful Sites   |   RSS   |   Help
© 2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites